The VA Says It Granted 60% of Claims. Nobody's Talking About the Other 40%.

Brad Cummings • 25 September 2026

Share this article

Three million decisions, 75 days each, 94% accuracy. The number that decides your case is buried at the end of the release.

Clipboard with papers and pen on a reception counter in a bright modern lobby

On Tuesday the VA announced it had processed more than three million disability claims this fiscal year, a record, with a week still to go. The average decision now takes 75.6 days, down from 141.5 in January 2025. The backlog is down more than 70 percent. Accuracy is at 94 percent, the highest in two years. More than 60 percent of claims are granted.


Those are the numbers the press release leads with, and they describe a system that is faster than it has been in a generation. Then, near the end, one more figure: only about 3 percent of the Veterans Benefits Administration's decisions are reviewed by the Board of Veterans' Appeals.


Read those together and a different story appears.


The math the release doesn't do


If more than 60 percent of claims are granted, then something under 40 percent are denied or, in practice, granted at a lower rating or later date than the veteran sought. On three million decisions, that's north of a million outcomes the veteran didn't want.

Only about 3 percent of decisions reach the Board. The Board isn't the only review lane, and some veterans use higher-level review or supplemental claims without ever going to a judge. But the gap between "roughly 40 percent unfavorable" and "roughly 3 percent reviewed at the Board" is enormous, and no amount of lane-counting closes it. The overwhelming majority of veterans who get a decision they disagree with do nothing about it.


That's the fact underneath the release, and the VA published it.


Why 94% accuracy and 40% denials both fit


Accuracy, as the VA measures it, means the decision correctly applied the rules to the record in front of the rater. A denial can be perfectly accurate on a thin file and still wrong about the veteran, because the file never contained the medical opinion or the records that would have changed it. The accuracy figure measures the rater. It says nothing about whether the evidence was complete.


And 94 percent still leaves 6 percent. On three million decisions, that's roughly 180,000 decisions the VA's own quality review would call wrong. The inspector general, as we wrote in August, tends to find more error than internal reviews do.


What speed does to the odds


Faster is good. A veteran waiting 75 days instead of 141 is a real improvement, and the department deserves credit for it. But the same release credits automated tools for streamlining routine work, and automation processes what a file contains rather than what it implies. We've written about what that shift means for how a claim should be built. The short version is that a thin file gets a fast, accurate, unfavorable decision, and the system considers that a success.


The case for appealing, from the VA's own release


Put the pieces together. Four in ten decisions go against the veteran in some way. Independent review, when it happens, finds errors at high rates. And almost nobody asks for it. Every one of those facts argues the same direction: if your decision came back wrong, the odds that it's fixable are better than the 3 percent figure would suggest, because the 3 percent measures how many veterans asked for review, and says nothing about how many decisions deserved it.


A denial is a decision on a file, made in 75 days, by a system optimized for throughput. It says less about your condition than it feels like it does. Read it closely, and if it doesn't hold up against your record, the review lanes exist because decisions like that are ordinary.


Where we come in


We're a veteran-led firm, and our whole practice lives in the gap between the 40 percent and the 3 percent: the decisions that went wrong and the veterans who assumed nothing could be done. If you're holding one, reach out and we'll tell you whether it deserves a second look.

Recent Posts

Single-story house at dusk with mountains in the background and a lit front porch.
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
Four ways to pass on a house in Colorado: will, joint title, beneficiary deed, or trust. What each does to the veteran tax exemption and a VA loan.
Hand placing a letter into a blue mailbox outdoors
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
Both Star Act bills key on the CRSC combat-related determination. Who qualifies, the five categories, what to send with DD Form 2860, and appeals.
Two gold rings on a windowsill beside a child’s drawing of a house and sun.
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
The House veterans package would end the remarriage penalty for surviving spouses, add $833 a month at top SMC tiers, and raise VA refinance fees.
Bedroom bedside table with a CPAP machine, hose, mask, and lit lamp at night
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
The House passed new sleep apnea and tinnitus criteria for claims filed on or after October 1, 2026. What’s protected, what isn’t, what to document.
Two folded paper envelopes, one cream and one gray, on a dark table with a pencil between them.
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
The House passed the standalone Star Act 392-18 and a package version by voice vote. Who each covers, what each pays, and the Senate’s four options.
Open drawer in a wooden nightstand with a dark-covered book on top and papers inside.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
The TSP pays by beneficiary form, not your will. What a surviving spouse’s account does at the second death, and the rollover that avoids a lump sum.
Six wall clocks arranged in two rows on a light-colored wall.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Correction boards must decide 90% of cases in 10 months. Review boards have no deadline. The GAO’s numbers for all six boards, and how to shorten it.
Empty checkpoint booth on a road with a lowered barrier gate, surrounded by autumn trees.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
The bill to legalize paid claims consultants died with the House majority. The bill to penalize them gets a chairman in January. What changes.
Stack of papers and folders on a desk, with a white sheet on top.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Duty-to-assist errors rose from 66,000 to 329,000 as the VA’s claims software spread. What the tool misses, why that helps your appeal, what to file.
Desk with a set of keys on a black case in an office chair and table setting.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Control of Congress flips in January. The Star Act, the tinnitus and sleep apnea offset, the COLA bill, December 11, and oversight: what changes.
Show More