The House Passed the Star Act Twice in Two Days. The Two Versions Don't Pay the Same.

Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026

Share this article

One bill, two texts, 58,000 retirees. What each version would put in your account, and what the Senate does with them.

On Veterans Day the House passed the Take Care of America's Veterans Act by voice vote, a package of more than 60 provisions that carries its own version of the Major Richard Star Act. The next afternoon it passed the standalone Star Act, 392 to 18 (Roll Call 323), after the discharge petition we wrote about in October forced it to the floor. Both bills are now in the Senate. Both would end the offset that takes retired pay away from combat-injured medical retirees dollar for dollar. They don't cover the same people, they don't pay the same amount, and they don't cost the same.


If you're a Chapter 61 retiree, the difference between the two texts is the difference in your monthly deposit.


The standalone bill is narrower than the one you've been reading about


The text the House voted on Thursday isn't the Star Act that was introduced in 2025. The resolution attached to the discharge petition swapped in a revised version, and the Congressional Budget Office scored it on October 27.


The original bill did three things beyond ending the offset for combat-injured retirees with fewer than 20 years. It opened Concurrent Retirement and Disability Pay to every Chapter 61 retiree under 20 years, combat-related or not. It lifted the cap on that pay for disability retirees with 20 or more years. And it ended the offset for combat-disabled retirees past 20 years. The revised text drops all three. What's left is the core: a Chapter 61 retiree with fewer than 20 years of service and a combat-related disability gets full retired pay and full VA compensation.


That's why the price changed. CBO put the original at $78.1 billion over ten years. It puts the version that passed at $12.75 billion. If you've seen the larger figure in older coverage, including ours, it belongs to a bill that's no longer on the table.

It's also why the population is smaller than the headlines suggest. About 58,000 retirees fit the bill as passed, the ones already drawing Combat-Related Special Compensation with under 20 years. Chapter 61 retirees whose disabilities aren't combat-related are outside both versions.


What the standalone bill pays


CBO's averages tell the story. The typical eligible retiree loses about $2,275 a month in retired pay to the offset. CRSC gives back about $825 of it. The bill would end the offset entirely, so the average retiree comes out about $1,450 a month ahead, roughly $17,400 a year. Your own number depends on your retired pay, your VA rating, and how much CRSC you draw today.


The change would take effect the first day of the month after the President signs it, as Military.com reads the bill. It isn't retroactive. There's no back pay for the years the offset ran, and there's nothing to apply for until a bill becomes law.


What the package version pays


The Star Act provision inside the package, section 101 of the bill as rewritten by an amendment before the vote, uses a formula the standalone doesn't. For a retiree with fewer than 20 years, it restores the lesser of two amounts: your Chapter 61 retired pay, or what a 20-year retirement would pay on the same pay base.


For many retirees those are the same number or close to it. For a retiree with a high military disability rating and few years in, they aren't. Disability retired pay runs up to 75% of the pay base. A 20-year retirement pays 50% of it under the legacy system and 40% under the Blended Retirement System. Take a pay base of $4,000 and a 70% military rating: the retired pay is $2,800 a month. The standalone bill restores all $2,800. Under the package's cap, as we read the text, the figure would be $2,000, or $1,600 for a blended-system retiree. A retiree whose military rating is 30% to 50% wouldn't see a difference.


The package does reach one group the standalone bill leaves out: disability retirees with 20 or more years whose combat-related condition is rated below the 50% line that concurrent receipt requires.


And the package comes with its financing attached. It pays for its benefits in part by changing how sleep apnea and tinnitus are rated for newer claims, which is a separate story with its own date problem.


The two arguments, stated fairly


Backers of the package, including the chairmen of both veterans' committees, say it's the only version with a way to pay for itself, that it delivers 60 other measures for survivors, caregivers, and severely disabled veterans along with the Star Act, and that the Senate has refused a standalone bill without an offset for years. The House chairman has called the package "the only viable path forward," Stars and Stripes reported. The administration has supported parts of the package and raised concerns about others, according to Military.com.


Backers of the standalone bill, including the VFW, DAV, and the other organizations that stood with its sponsors when the petition was called up, say one group of disabled veterans shouldn't be paid by lowering ratings for another, and that at $12.75 billion the revised bill is small enough to pass by itself. It carried 392 votes, including the Speaker's, by Military.com's account of the tally.


The Senate, and the calendar


The Senate companion to the standalone bill has 81 cosponsors, by the Military Officers Association's count, which Military Times cited. That's more than the 60 it takes to end debate. The obstacle has never been the count. There's no discharge petition in the Senate, floor time belongs to the majority leader, and every attempt to pass the bill by unanimous consent this Congress has been stopped by a single senator objecting to the cost, as Stars and Stripes has reported. The chairman of the Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee has said he looks forward to the package becoming law. The committee's ranking member, who sponsors the standalone bill, has said the package "will be defeated in the Senate." Both statements are in Military.com's report on the vote.


The session ends January 3. Between now and then the Senate has a December 11 funding deadline and the defense bill. Four outcomes are possible. The Senate passes the standalone bill as is and it goes to the President. The Senate passes the package. The Senate writes a hybrid and sends it back to the House. Or the clock runs out, and if it does, both bills die and start over in a Congress under new management.


What to do while the Senate decides


Check which kind of retirement you have. Both bills reach retirees under Chapter 61. If you were separated with severance pay instead of retired, neither one touches you, and the route to this benefit runs through a correction of your record first.


Get the combat-related determination on file. Both bills define eligibility by the same statute CRSC uses, and CBO built its count from the CRSC rolls. If you've never applied, or you were denied before this year's rulings widened the definition, that application is the one step that's yours to take. We've laid out how.


Don't pay anyone to "file" for the Star Act. There's no application, and there won't be one before there's a law.


Where we come in


We're a veteran-led firm, and untangling retired pay, CRSC, and VA compensation is the kind of records-and-money fight we handle, along with the corrections that turn a separation into the retirement it should have been. If you can't tell whether either bill would reach you, reach out.

Recent Posts

Single-story house at dusk with mountains in the background and a lit front porch.
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
Four ways to pass on a house in Colorado: will, joint title, beneficiary deed, or trust. What each does to the veteran tax exemption and a VA loan.
Hand placing a letter into a blue mailbox outdoors
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
Both Star Act bills key on the CRSC combat-related determination. Who qualifies, the five categories, what to send with DD Form 2860, and appeals.
Two gold rings on a windowsill beside a child’s drawing of a house and sun.
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
The House veterans package would end the remarriage penalty for surviving spouses, add $833 a month at top SMC tiers, and raise VA refinance fees.
Bedroom bedside table with a CPAP machine, hose, mask, and lit lamp at night
by Brad Cummings • 15 November 2026
The House passed new sleep apnea and tinnitus criteria for claims filed on or after October 1, 2026. What’s protected, what isn’t, what to document.
Open drawer in a wooden nightstand with a dark-covered book on top and papers inside.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
The TSP pays by beneficiary form, not your will. What a surviving spouse’s account does at the second death, and the rollover that avoids a lump sum.
Six wall clocks arranged in two rows on a light-colored wall.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Correction boards must decide 90% of cases in 10 months. Review boards have no deadline. The GAO’s numbers for all six boards, and how to shorten it.
Empty checkpoint booth on a road with a lowered barrier gate, surrounded by autumn trees.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
The bill to legalize paid claims consultants died with the House majority. The bill to penalize them gets a chairman in January. What changes.
Stack of papers and folders on a desk, with a white sheet on top.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Duty-to-assist errors rose from 66,000 to 329,000 as the VA’s claims software spread. What the tool misses, why that helps your appeal, what to file.
Desk with a set of keys on a black case in an office chair and table setting.
by Brad Cummings • 7 November 2026
Control of Congress flips in January. The Star Act, the tinnitus and sleep apnea offset, the COLA bill, December 11, and oversight: what changes.
Two people sitting on a wooden porch bench, looking off to the left, with a beige wall behind them.
by Brad Cummings • 30 October 2026
The Survivor Benefit Plan is a lifetime, inflation-indexed asset no will controls. What it pays, how it reshapes the plan, and the windows to act.
Show More